Town Marshal
James Joshua Payne
Fairmount Town Marshal's Office
Thursday, November 26, 1903
Age: 56
Served: 6 months
Panel 31E, Line 33 (2022)
Included (2022)
Fairmount Town Marshal's Office

Incident Details

Cause of Death
Gunfire
Date/Time of Incident
Thursday, November 26, 1903
01:40 pm
Incident to Death Duration
Same day
Incident Location
Fifth and Main streets, Fairmount
Incident County
Grant
Incident Township
Fairmount
Weapon Used
.38-caliber handgun
Suspect Disposition
Died in prison
Burial Place
Park Cemetery, Fairmount
Share this memorial

   Town Marshal James Payne was shot and killed while serving an arrest warrant on a subject for burglarizing a clothing store the previous evening.

   He and a deputy marshal took the 35-year-old man into custody and as they proceeded to walk toward the jail, the subject pulled a revolver and began firing at the officers.

   Marshal Payne was fatally shot through the heart after he returned fire striking the man once. The suspect held back a gathering crowd, firing at citizens who came to assist Marshal Payne as he lay dying in the street, before he made his escape out of town.

   The parolee, who had been released from prison six months earlier while serving a two-year sentence for burglary, was apprehended three days later by police in Tiffin, Ohio.

   He was extradited, subsequently convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison where he died in 1941.

   Town Marshal Payne was elected to a two-year term and survived by his wife, two sons and sister.

Military Service


United States Army
Civil War (Union)
Private (PVT) ▪ 1864–1865
Read more on our research at Honoring Our Fallen Town Marshals.



View all fallen officers from the
Fairmount Town Marshal's Office

Donate in memory of
Town Marshal Payne