Thomas Cummins
Jefferson Township Constable's Office
Tuesday, September 28, 1886

Age: 40
Served: 10 years
Badge #:
Military Service:
Panel 56W, Line 28

Incident Details

Cause of Death:
Date/Time of Incident:
Tuesday, September 28, 1886
03:00 pm
Incident to Death Duration:
Same day
Incident Location:
Incident County:
Incident Township:
Weapon Used:
Suspect Info:
Sentenced to 2 years
Burial Location:
Bethlehem-Mentor Cemetery, Dubois County

   Constable Thomas Cummins was shot and killed while attempting to arrest a subject for illegally carrying concealed weapons.

   The subject had come to the area claiming to be a private detective and had made numerous illegal arrests. When confronted by Constable Cummins at a saloon in Birdseye, he was shot in the abdomen by the man with a revolver concealed in his coat sleeve. Constable Cummins was taken to a house nearby and died about a half-hour later.

   The suspect escaped into the woods after shooting Constable Cummins but turned himself in the following week. He was later found guilty of voluntary manslaughter and sentenced to two years in prison.

   Constable Cummins was survived by his wife, ten children, brother and father.

The responsibilities of the Jefferson Township Constable's Office are now under the jurisdiction of the Dubois County Sheriff's Department.